Are Mechanical Keyboards Louder?

Introduction

Mechanical keyboards have gained popularity among computer enthusiasts and typists due to their tactile feedback and improved typing experience. However, one common question that arises is whether mechanical keyboards are louder than their traditional counterparts. In this article, we’ll explore the reasons behind the perceived loudness of mechanical keyboards, the different types of mechanical switches, and tips for quieter typing.

What is a Mechanical Keyboard?

Before diving into the noise factor, let’s understand what exactly a mechanical keyboard is. Unlike membrane keyboards, which rely on a rubber dome to register keypresses, mechanical keyboards use individual mechanical switches beneath each keycap. These switches provide a more responsive and tactile typing experience.

The Sound Factor: Why Are Mechanical Keyboards Louder?

One of the distinguishing characteristics of mechanical keyboards is their audible click or clack sound when typing. The sound produced by mechanical keyboards is primarily due to the design and construction of the switches. Mechanical switches consist of multiple components, including a spring and a stem that make contact when a key is pressed. When the stem hits the bottom, it creates a sound that is often associated with mechanical keyboards.

Types of Mechanical Keyboards

Mechanical keyboards come in various types, categorized based on the type of switch they use. Let’s explore the three main types of mechanical switches and their sound characteristics:

Linear Switches

Linear switches have a smooth keystroke without any tactile feedback or audible click sound. They are generally considered the quietest type of mechanical switches. The absence of a tactile bump reduces the noise level, making linear switches a preferred choice for those who want a quieter typing experience.

Tactile Switches

Tactile switches provide a subtle bump or tactile feedback when a key is actuated. They offer a balance between a smooth keystroke and a tactile feel. While they are not as loud as clicky switches, tactile switches can still produce some noise, albeit at a lower level.

Clicky Switches

Clicky switches are known for their audible click sound, which occurs when the key is pressed and released. The sound is generated by a mechanism within the switch that produces an audible click to confirm the actuation of the key. Clicky switches tend to be the loudest among the three types, making them popular among typists who enjoy the audible feedback.

Factors Influencing Keyboard Noise

Apart from the switch type, several other factors contribute to the overall noise level of a mechanical keyboard. These factors include:

Switch Type

As discussed earlier, the type of mechanical switch used in a keyboard plays a significant role in determining its noise level. Linear switches are generally quieter than tactile or clicky switches.

Keycap Material

The material used for the keycaps can affect the sound produced by a mechanical keyboard. Keycaps made of thicker and denser materials tend to dampen the noise, while thinner keycaps may result in a louder typing sound.

Keyboard Construction

The construction and design of the keyboard itself can impact the noise level. Mechanical keyboards with solid and sturdy frames tend to minimize vibrations and reduce the overall noise.

Typing Technique

Individual typing techniques can also influence the perceived loudness of a mechanical keyboard. Heavy typists who strike the keys forcefully may generate more noise compared to those with a lighter touch.

Advantages of Mechanical Keyboards

While the noise factor may be a concern for some, mechanical keyboards offer several advantages over their membrane counterparts. These include:

1. Enhanced typing experience and tactile feedback.
2. Improved durability and longevity.
3. Customizability with various switch options.
4. N-key rollover for accurate and simultaneous keypress registration.
5. Reduced typing fatigue due to optimal key actuation force.

Disadvantages of Mechanical Keyboards

Despite their advantages, mechanical keyboards are not without drawbacks. It’s important to consider the following aspects:

1. Higher cost compared to membrane keyboards.
2. Increased weight and bulkiness, making them less portable.
3. Potential noise disturbance in quiet environments.
4. Learning curve for individuals accustomed to membrane keyboards.

Tips for Quieter Typing on Mechanical Keyboards

If you enjoy the benefits of mechanical keyboards but prefer a quieter typing experience, consider the following tips:

1. Opt for keyboards with linear or tactile switches, as they tend to produce less noise compared to clicky switches.
2. Invest in keycaps made from materials designed to dampen sound, such as PBT (polybutylene terephthalate).
3. Consider using keyboard dampening accessories, such as o-rings or keyboard silencing foam, to reduce the noise produced by key bottoming out.
4. Adjust your typing technique to strike the keys more softly, minimizing the noise generated during typing.
5. Place a desk mat or a soft surface underneath your keyboard to absorb vibrations and reduce the overall noise level.

Are There Quieter Alternatives?

If you prefer a quieter typing experience but still want the benefits of a mechanical keyboard, there are alternatives available. Some keyboards feature “silent” or “quiet” switches specifically designed to reduce the noise level. These switches utilize various mechanisms to dampen the sound, such as rubber dampeners or modified stem designs. Exploring these alternatives can help you find a mechanical keyboard that suits your preferences.

Conclusion

In conclusion, mechanical keyboards can indeed be louder than their membrane counterparts due to the design and construction of the switches. However, the noise level varies depending on the type of switch used, typing technique, and other factors. While the audible feedback is a defining characteristic of mechanical keyboards, there are ways to minimize the noise without compromising the typing experience. By taking into account factors such as switch type, keycap material, and keyboard construction, you can discover a mechanical keyboard that achieves the ideal equilibrium between performance and noise level.

FAQs

Q1: Are mechanical keyboards only used by gamers? 

A1: No, mechanical keyboards are not limited to gamers. They are popular among typists, programmers, and anyone seeking an improved typing experience.

Q2: Can I customize the sound of my mechanical keyboard? 

A2: While you can’t completely change the sound produced by the switch mechanism, you can adjust the overall noise level by choosing quieter switches, using dampening accessories, or modifying your typing technique.

Q3: Are all mechanical keyboards loud? 

A: No, the noise level of mechanical keyboards varies depending on the switch type, keycap material, and keyboard construction. Linear switches and certain “silent” switch variants offer quieter alternatives.

Q4: Can I use O-rings to reduce the noise of my mechanical keyboard? 

A4: Yes, o-rings can help reduce the noise produced by key bottoming out. They act as shock absorbers and dampen the sound when the keycap hits the switch housing.

Q5: Do mechanical keyboards improve typing speed? 

A5: While mechanical keyboards can enhance the typing experience, they may not necessarily improve typing speed on their own. Typing speed depends on various factors, including individual skill, practice, and familiarity with the keyboard layout.